Student Loans: Pros and Cons

Posted: August 25, 2009 in Blogging, Community, Consumer Issues, Credit, economy, education, Friends, Life, Saving, School
Tags: , , , , , , , ,

I paid for school out of my own pocket.  My wife and I didn’t qualify for any of the number of Financial Aid products out there, and our choice was either to go with student loans or to pay out of pocket.  Throughout the past few years, several of my friends went through the process of applying for Financial Aid, and many of them got student loans.  In fact, students today are convinced by teachers, counselors, parents, and peers that they cannot go to school without student loans.  I thought today would be a good time to discuss student loans and other financial aid products.

I’ve talked about the differences between the different products in a post last year called “Getting a Job FTW”.  Spoiler alert:  I believe that paying your own way through school is the best way if you can do it.  This is coming up now because I have a family member who is considering getting some student loans to pay for some classes.

I like the idea of student loans if there is no other option.  For most people, I think there are always other options.  But once in a while, someone finds him or herself in a position where they need to take a few student loans to pay for tuition and books.  I want to be clear here:  I have little problem with student loans if used in this manner.  Where I have a problem is this conversation that I have had with a few students that I have known.

“I’m going to get a student loan, pay for school and take the rest to fix my car.”

“Well, aren’t those loans for school?”

“It’s my money anyway, and I’m paying it back after I graduate.”


See, too often, young people can get trapped to use a student loan to finance their existence.  This puts an interest rate on something that usually doesn’t have one.  It is doubly stupid to use a student loan to pay something that is already borrowed, such as making a car payment.  I have a friend that took their student loan check and paid some credit card payments and a car payment.  Their belief was that they were saving money because they were able to pay their credit card with a loan that had a much lower interest rate.  Sounds good, but it is utterly incorrect.  Let’s look at what we are doing:


Student Loan:  $5,000.00

Car payment:  $300.00
Credit Card:  $500.00

– $800.00
Leaves:  $4,200.00

Semester of Classes and books:  $5,100.00
Credit Card Advance: $900.00


So now you have made a payment at around 5% interest on your 18% credit card, but you have taken almost twice as much out of that same credit card for %20 or more.  You still owe the entire $5,000.00 as well.  What have you accomplished?  You have increased your debt.

Is there a better way?  Sure.  Get a job and maybe slow down your education.  Not only does this help you avoid debt, but there is one even more important benefit.

Speaking only of my own industry, education, our classrooms are filled with pinheads who have never spent a day outside of the classroom in their lives.  They don’t have any idea how the real world works, and therefore give bad advice based on misinformation they have been fed throughout their sheltered lives.  Students who ask these people for life advice (as students frequently do) are given cookie-cutter advice that rarely answers the initial question.  They shun those who think as individuals, and praise those who follow the herd.  In short, they do a disservice to the individuality that young people struggle to master.

You might be thinking that I am a little hard on my peers, calling them unexperienced pinheads, but too many of my peers blissfully walk through life with their eyes covered in an effort to avoid any of that real-world experience that is so crucial to the human experience. 

All of them also have student loans.

So in short, if you are one of those few who have to get student loans, use the money wisely.  Use the money on tuition, books, supplies, or other things that go directly to school.  Ignore the idea that these loans are deferred until after you graduate, and make payments whenever possible.  The only way to do this is to decrease the time spent in school and increase the time spent at work.  Above all, avoid paying any bill that is not directly related to school, and never pay off something that carries its own interest rate with the proceeds from a student loan.

Add to FacebookAdd to NewsvineAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Furl

  1. […] post: Student Loans: Pros and Cons Subscribe to comments Comment | Trackback | Post Tags: car-dealers, choice, consumer, […]

  2. […] original here: Student Loans: Pros and Cons Share and […]

  3. Jacob says:

    You are 100% on target with this article. I paid my way through school; but, my wife didn’t. So I’ve seen both sides first hand. Believe me, five years after school, you’ll be cursing those student loans.

  4. Loan Advice says:

    Very very interesting post..I like this one. gotta bookmark this one.
    Loan Advice

  5. nice info about the pros and cons of the student loan. any way we must take some steps that reduce the risk and increase the advantages of the student loan. loans foe students are the essential tool of the success of the community. it is admitted fact that the risk is involve in every step that is taken by the person but there is a famous quotation that high risk high return.

  6. Wil says:

    @medical schools

    Thanks for reading and for the comment. I have to strongly disagree with your assertion that student loans are the essential tool of the success of the community. These products are only essential for the lenders. Students are doing a disservice to themselves by falling for this unless there is NO other way. In most cases, they would be better off taking fewer classes and extending their time in college (part-time) while working to pay for school. What they accomplish will be free and clear, and not accompanied by debt that too frequently is more than the degree is workth.

  7. provides good repairing says:

    I was more than happy to find this great site.
    I want to to thank you for ones time for this fantastic read!!
    I definitely appreciated every little bit of
    it and I have you book marked to look at new information in your web site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s